Home Page

Welcome to

The Cookie Jar

PASTRY SHOP
Order Online

Discover

Our Story

A local icon since the 1950’s.
We guarantee the highest quality in everything we do.

About Us

Menu

Original

Recipes

SINCE 1949

Explore

Our Menu

We carry all your favorites: fresh turnovers, whoopie pies,
cream rolls, gingerbread men and, of course, donuts.
We make sandwiches and soups daily for a quick lunch
and have seasonal items too.

View The Full Menu

Cakes

The Perfect

Cake

FOR EVERY OCCASION

Absolutely

delicious

Our wedding and all occasion cakes are baked fresh
from scratch. Each cake is unique and prepared
especially for you on your special day.

Order Online

 

 

Reviews

Customer

Reviews

OUR CUSTOMERS are like family

    star rating  We were exploring Cape Elizabeth when we saw this pastry shop. I like the simplicity and a hommie feels. The pastries were delicious. One of the places to See.

    avatar thumb Dprudenc
    August 6, 2018

    star rating  What a great selection of cookies and pastries. The donuts are huge. Especially like the raspberry and date filled sugar cookies. Recommend the freshly baked breads and rolls too. Always... read more

    avatar thumb MayVegas17
    February 18, 2019

    star rating  Donna the owner and her staff were a joy to work with. I emailed her some ideas I wanted for my son's birthday cake and the end result was... read more

    avatar thumb Carrie N
    February 13, 2019

    star rating  Been here several times right when they opened. Staff was pleasant and service was quick. On one occasion, I stopped to pick up "day old" donut holes (a bunch of... read more

    Ha-p-2-b-home-n-ME
    September 11, 2019